Islam the Church Theology

Islam’s version of the Feeding of the 5,000 and a Christmas Letter to St Thomas’s

Every couple of weeks I have the privilege of writing the St Thomas’s pastoral letter.  I thought I would share with you this weeks.

Brothers and Sisters,

This week I happened to come across one of the Islamic radio stations in Sydney. It was fascinating – the music included a soft rap version of the story of the prophet Noah, and the sermon was retelling the stories of the feeding of the 5,000 and the prodigal son, by the prophet Isa (Jesus).

In this version, from one of the Hadiths, according to the preacher, Muhammed is supposed to have taught that the feeding of the 5,000 was really the feeding of the 40,000 over a period of 40 days – where the food (various fruit) continually fed everyone. Until the 40th day when after that it was just the poor. However, there were 33 ‘unbelievers’ who were cursed and turned into pigs when they tried to eat the food. With tears in their eyes, they pleaded with Isa to put them out of their misery – which he did.

Earlier that afternoon I had been talking to a young dad who was at the St Thomas’ Preschool ‘graduation’ (by the way, what a wonderful work the preschool is – a great opportunity to serve the community and evidence the love of Christ – let the little children come to me). He mentioned that he thought there were many people in Sydney who were lost and without hope – because so many of the things people rely on have been proven not to be so reliable.

We have a great story to tell which brings real hope. The Islamic version was so depressing. It is a works religion which either drives people into despair or self-righteousness. I heard of a Christian religious leader who when asked what his hope for heaven was, replied, “I did my best”! That is not the Gospel. Indeed, it is the antithesis of the Gospel.

In the Gospel Jesus does not turn the unbelievers into pigs. He instead tells of the Father who welcomed the prodigal son back from eating with the pigs – and gave him a great feast. That is what Christmas is about.

The Islamic teacher pronounced ‘Isa, who was not crucified, and did not die’. That is not good news. Our good news is that Christ was born to die. We preach Christ crucified. That is our hope. In a world desperate for good news – our message has not changed from that of the angels to the shepherds – “I bring you good news of great joy that is for all the people”.

We have a better story. Let’s make sure we tell it.

This week’s resources:

A great devotional book for Christmas – full of rich, practical Bible teaching is Sinclair Ferguson’s Love Came Down at Christmas.
And this sermon from Sinclair is a wonderful exposition of the meaning of Christmas.

The song this week is Jars of Clay’s version of ‘Love Came Down at Christmas’. It’s a great wee video to show the children as well.

Have a great Christmas!

Your brother,
David Robertson

Have Yourself A Merry Cromwellian Christmas – AP

The Visible Word and the Aaronic Blessing – Sinclair Ferguson


  1. Yes in Islam there is not the belief that Jesus died. So there is not the overcoming of death and therefore sin (for the wages of sin is death). Also worshipping Jesus is regarded as the worse kind of sin, the sin of shirk, of idolising something other than God.

    At the same time Jesus did refer to people as pigs (and also dogs) implicitly with giving the direction not to share pearls wiht swine or give what is sacred to dogs. So there is some commonality there. But his message was also of love of enemies. If your enemy thirsts, give him something to drink, and if he hungers, something to eat. So it had application practically as well as spiritually and relationally.

    In my experience, a Muslim will regard you as a believer but won’t want to think of you as a Christian if they like you because to them Christians do something which is abhorrent in worshipping Jesus and they would want you not to do that.

    I hear word of Muslims coming to faith in Jesus through dreams – have you heard similar David?

    1. From a Muslim background, I became a Christian following a vision of Jesus in the middle of the night. However, I was deeply influenced by meeting with a “born again” Christian before that happened. My autobiography is available and available from Amazon and it is called: “What’s up Doc? A Surgeon’s Story”. This will give a good view of my life journey.

  2. Some Muslims name their sons after Jesus ( Isa ) and while He is acknowledged as a Prophet , Jesus is not regarded as divine ; not even Mohammed is accorded that designation, being regarded as simply a messenger.

  3. Have a look at the current meltdown that the islamic Dawah (evangelic) scene is undergoing with one of their prominent scholars Yashir Qadi admitted on a podcast that the “standard narrative has holes” of a perfectly preserved Quran. The video was quickly edited with the incriminating part deleted and followed by the taking down of the whole video shortly afterwards but it has been too late and the damage has been done. some within and outside the islamic community are saying its the most damaging interview to islam within recent history.

  4. Good news. Will Islamists stop attacking us because of it .

    If your really want to impress people , you should direct them to the work of Princeton’s ( late ) Prof. Patricia Crone or the happily extant Prof. Michael Cook.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: