Africa Ethics Films Media

Christians – Please Stop Breaking the Ninth Commandment on Social Media!

Social media works in mysterious ways.  For some reason this meme keeps appearing on my feed.   Christians largely retweeting this story.  Please stop.

Screenshot 2019-10-16 18.51.35

Why are they doing this? Because it fits two narratives – firstly it is a great story.  And secondly it makes the point that the MSM (mainstream media) will ignore stories like this.  The only problem is – its’ false.  Have a look at this.

This was a film made by BBC films, Blue Sky films and others.  It was and is distributed worldwide on Netflix.   There have also been numerous articles and stories about it.  The media who are being demonised have already made William Kamkwamba.

The meme spreads a lie and demonstrates both prejudice and ignorance.  We are claiming something about the media which is demonstrably false, thus showing that we don’t actually know the media we are talking about.

From a Christian point of view – passing on falsehoods (even when we don’t know they are false) is sin.    Look at what the Shorter Catechism says about this (expounding the ninth commandment).   The larger is much longer and more detailed but is well worth us paying attention to.

Q. 77. What is required in the ninth commandment?

A. The ninth commandment requireth the maintaining and promoting of truth between man and man, and of our own and our neighbour’s good name, especially in witness bearing.

Q. 78. What is forbidden in the ninth commandment?

A. The ninth commandment forbiddeth whatsoever is prejudicial to truth, or injurious to our own, or our neighbour’s, good name

Can I suggest first of all that we be very careful what we retweet and pass on – even (or especially) when it comes from someone we trust?  If they are just passing on a false meme then that trust is misplaced.  It’s not too difficult to check on most things.  If we are going to pass on gossip, or harmful information, we need to make sure both that the information is true – and that we have a good reason for passing it on (ie. warning the Lord’s people about false teaching).   But we MUST stop passing on things just because they suit our prejudices.

There is also an element of arrogance and pride in this meme as well.  “we” will make him famous – because the MSM won’t.  No we won’t. And why should we want to?  It’s a lovely, moving and powerful story – let’s not destroy it with our pride, ignorance and prejudices.

By the way – the film is fantastic….Watch it and be thankful.

Saturday Review 12 – John Milton; Titania McGarth; Marilynne Robinson; Melvyn Bragg on Tyndale; Quillette; Tim Shipman; The Boy Who Harnessed the Wind; Australia with Julia Bradbury; Runrig

11 comments

  1. Completely agree with not passing on things because it suits prejudices.

    This applies to semons as much as it does to facebook re-postings and more so, for teachers will be judged more harshly.

  2. As a general rule, if a post contains any of the following it’s pure sharebait:
    “I bet I won’t even get one share”
    “If this post gets xxx,yyy likes/shares…”
    “If you love Jesus share this post and comment ‘Amen’ to prove it or you’re denying Him so He’ll deny you”

    When someone starts sharing these repeatedly on my feed, they can expect a rapid unfriend/unfollow from me.

  3. Everything you wrote in that post is 100% true and theologically irrefutable.

    Sadly, it only applies to Jews , for whom this Hebrew lore and mythology – based precept was devised. Just for the Chosenites – not for us.

      1. The Babylonian Talmud is a wonderful masterpiece of ethno – centrism available, for now, on Kindle.

        “It is permitted to deceive a Goi.”

        Talmud : Babha Kama 113b

        Please do not shoot the messenger.

      2. I won’t shoot the messenger but at least get the message right. I would advise that you do not quote mine….Baba Kama does not say that it is ok for Jews to lie to Gentiles. A text without a context is just a pretext. Baba Kama 113b is in the context of slavery…and it could be argued that it says exactly the opposite of what you say. There are of course some circumstances where it is permitted to lie…

  4. I tend to avoid personal questions but how do you , being a busy salvation advocate , avoid questions regarding the earthly disappointment of your congregations’s non – answered prayers?

Leave a Reply to Alastair Ross Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: