As I have gradually got back into public speaking its been a privilege to speak at the Universities of Aberdeen, Abertay, Dundee….The CU’s generally do a remarkable work. I think what I personally enjoy more than anything are the discussions and debates with non-believers. They don’t always have to be hostile. As the following example shows – this was held in the Glasgow Uni Student Uni with one of my favourite atheist speakers – Gary McLelland – who is now the International director of the International Humanist and Ethical Union. Gary is a lapsed Catholic – articulate, intelligent and gracious. I have a lot of time for him. This particular debate covered many of the normal questions and objections – what I remember about it was the discussion in the bar afterwards with some of the atheists….it both challenged and reinforced my faith. Atheism is the ultimate delusion –
I have been asked several times in the past few weeks to give examples of debates so this is perhaps the clearest.
Here is another that we did in Strathclyde –
Is Belief in God Reasonable? Debate with Gary McLelland
Finally if you want an example of a debate that is not quite so peaceful – I guess my favourites are the two I did on Premier with Matt Dillahunty – I found him to be the opposite of Gary – smug and self-righteous – getting caught in the trap of his self-awareness of his own genius. He was a classic example of the ‘give them enough rope and they will hang themselves principle’! The atheist backlash on this one was furious – which showed to me that it had touched a nerve.
The Atheist Experience – First Debate with Matt Dillahunty – Why I am not an Atheist
I’ve listen to both of your exchanges with Dillahunty on Premier a number of times – I quite enjoyed them. The last thing I came away thinking was that Matt was “smug and self-righteous”, there are a few occasions where his tone seems to suggest frustration or irritation but that’s because of your own tendency to talk over the top of him.