Australia Bible Christianity Evangelism Free Church Newspaper/Magazine Articles The Church in Scotland

The Dangerous Betrayal of Scotland’s Christian Heritage – Article in The Daily Mail – Easter Saturday 2016


Last week I received a phone call asking me if I would be willing to write the Mail’s Easter essay!  Is the Pope a Catholic?!  It was actually a difficult task (2,000 words) and to be honest I was not sure if they would take it.  Apart from a few edits to the first paragraphs they have printed it in full!  I am so thankful for this opportunity to proclaim the Good News in the national secular press.  As men that dreamed were we!

My original article is below – but I would suggest you buy the Scottish Daily Mail today (Easter Saturday) – and thank them  – if you enjoy the article!

Scotland needs an Easter Revolution  (They changed the headline to the above). 

 It’s Easter.  Time for Easter bunnies, crowded roads and of course Easter chocolate eggs.  But as regards the latter, not for long. Sainsbury’s, Nestle and Cadbury’s have apparently removed Easter from our seasonal chocolate. Why?  These are commercial companies and they obviously think that the term Easter is either meaningless or indeed offensive.  It is a classic indicator of the decline of Christianity in what our Prime Minister calls ‘Christian’ Britain.  Do the chocolate companies have it right? Perhaps it is time to get Christianity out of Easter and out of Scotland?  Are we not after all a ‘progressive’ society that has outgrown the outdated and outmoded religion of our past?


Blame Religion – This week that view was further reinforced with the response to the Brussels’s attacks. Many journalists and commentators were careful to speak of religious terrorists and religious motivation. This was reflected in the various social media outlets used by secularist and humanist groups. You could hear plenty vox pox of the ‘man in the street’ proclaiming ‘its all these religious people’. And thus a form of extremist Islamic terrorism in Belgium suddenly becomes a reason to close Catholic schools in Scotland! Mother Teresa and Osama Bin Laden have morphed into the same figure. Together with John Lennon, people imagine that if only there were no religion then there would nothing to kill or die for.

The Shrinking Church  – That is a message that seems to be getting through. Despite brave words and desperate massaging of figures the mainstream churches in Scotland appear to be in terminal decline. The Church of Scotland is hemorrhaging more than 20,000 people per year and its demographic is largely elderly. Polish and other immigrants are keeping the Roman Catholic Church from an equivalent collapse. Virtually every town and city in Scotland has boarded up church buildings and others that are only being kept open by legacies from the past. Government pays lip service to the establishment of Christianity, and the churches respond by supporting the Establishment.   Politicians seek to keep the churches on board knowing that they provide a great deal of the ‘Big Society’ which fills in the increasingly large holes caused by austerity, poverty and family breakdown. But the churches continue to shrink and the number of people professing ‘no-religion’ will soon be a majority. How can it be otherwise when many of our schools and media are increasingly being used for indoctrinating secular humanist values and philosophies into our children?

 And how do the churches respond? Some are in despair and like the last Mennonite community in Britain, which closed this year, have almost given up.   Others are in denial. There was a discussion on BBC Radio Scotland this week in which it was stated that whilst only 10% of the population regularly attend church, ‘research’ has shown that another 20% maintain an active and living Christian faith.   In the words of the prophet Victor Meldrew, “I don’t believe it’.     Apart from the fact that 10% of the population in most areas do not attend church (remember that there are lies, damn lies, and statistics!), it is a myth that there are more than a million plus Christians ‘out there’ in Scotland who have just disconnected from the church and just waiting for us to reconnect with them.  Desperately clutching at straws we speak of ‘the invisible church’ and comfort ourselves that there are far more Christians than we suspect. It is a mirage that makes professional clergy feel better about their jobs. Personally I think those who minister to the invisible church should get invisible salaries! You can state ‘I minister to 10,000 people in my parish’ whilst knowing that barely 100 of them ever bother to cross your door. The fact that you get to bury someone does not mean that they are part of Christ’s flock, or yours. Despair, denial and delusion are in deep.

Trivia and Heresy –   But this Easter will give us plenty other examples of why the churches are declining. The message from many pulpits will be mercifully short but nonetheless feel like an eternity, as ethereal waffle and meaningless verbiage is spouted.   I hope that there will be no ministers this Easter eating daffodils to illustrate how unbelievable the resurrection is. But the trivialization of Christianity is not our only problem. It is the undermining from within that is killing the church. Whether it is bishops pontificating from pulpits about the resurrection being ‘a conjuring trick with bones, or ministers writing in church magazines and national newspapers about the ‘myth of resurrection’ and the ‘deeper spiritual meaning’ before breaking into ‘all you need is love’ and making sure we all get the usual sound bites and buzzwords, the effect is still the same. The message of the Christian gospel comes across as sweet as Easter chocolate, as fluffy as Easter bunnies and as useless as a wet paper bag.

 Why does this matter?   It matters to those of us who are Christians, because like Christ, we love his church and we hate to see it in such a state. And it matters to those who are not Christians because if Scotland loses Christianity, it loses its heart and soul. The root of Scotland’s identity has been in Christian teaching. Our education, democracy, morality, liberty, equality, justice and values have stemmed from Christianity. Our anti-Christian secular humanists like to think that we will be able to retain the fruit of Christianity without having the roots. Theirs is an untried and untested faith that is as dangerous as it is delusional.  The removal of Christianity from the public square in Scottish life will be a disaster, not just for the Church, but also for the whole of the country, especially the poor.

But all is not lost. This week the BBC had a fascinating programme entitled The battle for Christianity in which Robert Beckford looked at the state of the Church in the UK. His conclusion was that immigration; radical social action, conservative morality and charismatic worship are changing the church.  In the church in Scotland we can see these same trends. Immigration has brought great benefit to many of us…I think of my own church, St Peters in Dundee, where we have members who are Australian, Malaysian, French, German, Dutch, African, American, Brazilian, Italian, Chinese, Polish, Estonian, English, Irish and even some Scots! Last night I met a student from Thailand who had just become a Christian. Radical social action such as the work of the Trussell Trust, Christians Against Poverty and the Bethany Trust, are showing the church works in our communities. Traditional morality is something that unites Christians of different denominations as we take our stand against the confused and confusing new morality of the liberal elites who seek to reshape us in their own image.  Last month I spoke at a Catholic church on the issue of abortion. A Free Church moderator speaking at a Catholic church even twenty years ago would have been considered unthinkable, but now we are being compelled to stand together. Of course there are professing Christians who just want to go along with the morality of the age, as there are those who neglect to serve the poor, but they forget the old adage that he who marries the spirit of this age, will be a widow in the next.   And there have been many changes in worship styles, allowing a diversity of styles and worship traditions.

 But we need more. It is exactly one hundred years since the Easter revolution in Ireland. Now Scotland needs its own version. Not an armed uprising or rebellion, but rather a recovery of the Christian Good news, the radical message that truly turns the world upside down. Matthew Parris, my favorite atheist writer, puts it superbly: “Now a confirmed atheist, I’ve become convinced of the enormous contribution that Christian evangelism makes in Africa: sharply distinct from the work of secular NGOs, government projects and international aid efforts. These alone will not do. Education and training alone will not do. In Africa Christianity changes people’s hearts. It brings a spiritual transformation. The rebirth is real. The change is good.” We need that rebirth.

There is a spiritual vacuum in Scotland today. An Australian family who recently moved to Scotland told me how astounded they were at the effects of militant secularism in our land. That shook me a bit as Australia is hardly a bastion of Christianity! We have fallen a long way, very quickly.  In Scotland we used to be known as the people of the Book, but as we have largely departed from our Christian roots, it has left a spiritual hole that will not be filled by materialism, secular humanism or any other ‘ism’.  There is a famine of hearing the Word of the Lord. A famine for which the church is largely responsible. We have turned away from the Word of the Lord and served up our own spiritual equivalent of junk food. In starving ourselves we have also starved others.   It is time for the church in Scotland to experience another reformation and renewal.

The centre of the Christian faith is the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ – that is why half of each gospel is taken up with these last few days of his life. This Easter Sunday we will celebrate the astonishing fact that Jesus is risen from the dead. The Anglican Michael Green summarises the importance of this: “The resurrection is the place to begin if you are looking for a satisfying faith on which to base your life. Do not waste a lot of time investigating every religion under the sun….examine the evidence for Jesus instead. If he is risen you need look no further”. Once you grasp the resurrection, you grasp the significance of the cross. As Paul told the Italians – he was declared with power to be the Son of God by his resurrection.   Once you grasp who Jesus is, then you can understand why he died (as the atoning sacrifice for our sins) and how his resurrection is the guarantee of ours. The message of Christianity is forgiveness, rebirth and eternal life.   “Jesus said to her, ‘I am the resurrection and the life. He who believes in me will live, even though he dies: and whoever lives and believes in me will never die. Do you believe this?” (John 11:25-26) The Easter message for Scotland today is that Christ is dead for you, and Christ is risen for you. The forgiveness, renewal and love that come through the cross is also the message for Brussels today.

It is a great message to preach. We don’t need to add to it. And we don’t need to take away from it.   I have been preaching this message and its implications for over 30 years and we are now beginning to see the fruit. We have seen the church grow from a handful to more than 250 and we have seen new churches planted in St Andrews and Montrose and are planning to start more in Dundee. We are not the only ones. There are other churches of different denominations like this in Scotland today. In reliance on the Holy Spirit they proclaim Jesus through his word; like their Father they serve the poor, care for the sick and welcome the stranger.   They remain faithful to the Bible. And they are growing.  I guess if God can raise Jesus from the dead, he can even revive and renew the church in Scotland!

I leave you with the words of a contemporary Easter hymn that will ring out across many churches in Scotland this Sunday. Happy Easter!

And we are raised with Him, 

Death is dead, love has won, Christ has conquered; 

And we shall reign with Him, 
For He lives: Christ is risen from the dead! (Townend/Getty).
David Robertson

Moderator of the Free Church of Scotland

St Peters Free Church











  1. “If Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile; you are still in your sins” 1Cor. 15, 17

    My youngest daughter, a solicitor, decided several years ago to seek the basis of faith for herself (as opposed to second hand belief from her parents). One of the first books she found was Frank Morison’s “Who move the stone”, a Christian classic on the resurrection and amazingly first published in 1930 (but still available today –

    The story of how the book came to be written is well known. My daughter found it, from a legal and forensic point of view, utterly compelling and it projected her along the path to a fully committed faith – she was baptised last year.

    I challenge any honest unbeliever to read this before dismissing the resurrection as myth or fantasy.

  2. Apart from journalistic motives, it is significant that you have been asked, not someone from the the numerical stronger CoS with its superficially greater cultural sway, and self perceived lack of a communication problem with todays society.

    Praise the LORD. I’m sure you’ll prefer to hear a deferred “well done” from Him!


  3. Hello Brother David

    That was very good. I found you by our mutual brother, Vincent. This article really resonated with me a lot. I am a Missionary Baptist of the American Baptist Association. It is ironic that for several years one of our nearby churches here in the state of Arkansas actually had a mission in Scotland. Alvin Dickerson, the missionary described it as a very difficult mission. Unfortunately, Brother Alvin became will with brain cancer and had to come home and finally died. I honestly don’t know if the mission is still running or not. Bless your work there.

  4. I do not know how many first generation immigrants attend Catholic churches in Scotland but I can accept that the number of people attending Mass at Saturday Vigil/Sunday morning has been in decline for quite some time. I can also accept that the number of priests being ordained has also declined significantly. I can also accept that churches are being closed and that more church closures are on the way. But I can also assure your readers that “The Easter message …. that Christ is dead for you, and Christ is risen for you” is most assuredly preached by Catholic priests the length and breadth of Scotland. At my local church on Good Friday, and this is typical of all Catholic churches in Scotland, we spent an hour and a half reflecting on the Crucifixion of Jesus Christ, including readings from Isaiah, Hebrews, and the entire Passion according to John. On Saturday evening, after nightfall, comes the Easter Vigil.
    “One of the unique aspects of the Easter Vigil is the recounting of the outstanding deeds of the history of salvation. These deeds are related in seven readings from the Old Testament chosen from the law and the prophets and two readings from the New Testament, namely from the Apostle Paul and from the Gospel. Thus, the Lord meets us once again on our journey and, “beginning with Moses and all the prophets” (Lk 24:27) opens up our minds and hearts, preparing us to share in the breaking of the bread and the drinking of the cup. The faithful are encouraged to meditate on these readings by the singing of a responsorial psalm, followed by a silent pause, and then by the celebrant’s prayer. Meditation on these readings is so significant for this night that we are strongly urged to use all the readings whenever it can be done. Only in the case of grave pastoral circumstances can the number of readings be reduced. In such cases, at least three readings from the Old Testament should be read, always including Exodus 14.”
    During the Easter Vigil and the Masses on Sunday morning, the homilies are always about the importance of the Resurrection.
    The practice of confession of sins to a priest is obviously not one which is approved by our Protestant friends in Christ (although it was approved by Luther) but whether you approve of it or not you may acknowledge that it is a powerful instrument for promoting an awareness of the state of our own sinfulness and our need for forgiveness. Catholics are encouraged to go to Confession throughout the year but especially at Easter time. Lent is a time of preparation when the emphasis is on conversion, renewal and penance. Good Friday is a time for reflecting on the Crucifixion and how our own sins are the real cause of that event. (As also is the service known as the Stations of the Cross which is performed throughout Lent.) Easter Sunday is a time for celebrating the Resurrection and all that it means in terms of our redemption.
    The number of baptised Catholics may be declining and the number of baptised Catholics who attend Mass may be declining but it is not for want of preaching the essential message of Easter.

  5. Mike 17

    Your contribution is appreciated and particularly “how our own sins are are the cause of that event. ” (the crucifixion). and your referrence to a basis of “biblical theology” in Luke 24:27 “Beginning with Moses” about how all of scripture is about Jesus, which at the same time is wonderfully trinitarian.

    In some protestant churches it is all too easy to breazily sing (paradoxically with a heavy heart) a wonderful contemporary song by Stuart Townend: “How deep the Father’s love for us” which contain the words,”behold a man upon a cross, my sin upon His shoulders…. It was my sin that held Him there, until it was accomplished, His dying breath has brought me life, I know that it is finished…” Yes, it’s sometimes easier to weep over His death and not over the depth of our sin.

    But I believe the significance of death and resurrection of Jesus can only truly be appreciated in our union with Him . Sinclair Fergson has some wonderful teaching/preaching about this Don’t know if David’s St Peter’s church has any links if you are interested. I think Thomas Merton had some deep musings on our union in his “Seeds of Contemplation”, but I think it has to be looked at with great caution as it seems to veer off into easterm mysticism or western existentialism.

  6. Excellent article!!! As a Scottish American, I visited Scotland last year for the first time and absolutely fell in love with the country of my heritage and I cried when I had to leave. I did notice the churches did not seem overly used, although they are all so beautiful. I have the flag of St.Andrew on my car and am glad to explain to people who ask who St. Andrew is. If the Christian faith had not been brought to Scotland they might still be following the druids now. LOL Dear Lord, do not let this beautiful country fall into the secularists hands. Please help the people of Scotland stand strong in their faith and start a new revival, Amen. God bless you all! Tracey “Watts” Bracy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: