Christianity Evangelism Scots Kirk St Peters Theology

Evangelism and the Holy Spirit

This is part 5 of my series on Evangelism in AP

Evangelism and the Holy Spirit

Following on from ‘Evangelism and the Bible’ https://ap.org.au/2026/11/13/evangelism-and-the-bible-part-4-of-evangelism/ have you ever noticed how ‘liberals’ use the idea of the Holy Spirit to contradict the book that the Spirit inspired? “Oh, we are not tied to the dead letter of a book, we have the Spirit guiding us”. Usually, they say this when they want to go against what God’s Word says…. I recall being told by the Church of Scotland that the Spirit had guided them to accept same sex marriage. But the Spirit, unlike so many churches, is not the author of confusion (1 Corinthians 14:33).

On the other hand, I have seen some charismatic churches, who talk a great deal about the Spirit and who, although they accept the Bible, more often refer to it as an illustration from the past, rather than the Word of God for today. There is a desperation to have God’s Word for today. They don’t seem to realise that we have it! When we started getting a lot of charismatics coming to our church in Dundee sometimes they would ask, ‘how do you preach’? My answer was ‘I preach prophetically’. Which in charismatic jargon was exactly what they wanted to hear. But I meant it. The Bible is the living and active Word of God – addressing us today in our context and culture as well as our own hearts. And for that to happen we need the Spirit.

 

I suspect that sometimes, in reaction to the charismatic theology, we are tempted to veer the other way. Any talk of the Spirit is reduced and explained away. That is so dangerous, so unbiblical and so unpresbyterian. It leads us into a managerial, project orientated, systematised corporate Christianity which grieves and quenches the Spirit.

Corporate or Spiritual?

One of the biggest cultural shocks for me when I came to Sydney to work in evangelism was to be asked what my KPI’s were. I didn’t even know what a KPI was! (Key Performance Indicator). When I was put out of my ignorance I responded, ‘people hearing the Word, people repenting, believing being converted and people being filled with the Holy Spirit’. Apparently that wasn’t what they were looking for. Funders wanted to know what they were funding and what bang they would get for their buck. It was the antithesis of biblical Christianity.

Was it A.W. Tozer who said that if the Holy Spirit was removed from the church, 90% of what we do would continue as if nothing had happened? If that’s true for the church in general, it is certainly true for evangelism. So much of it is technique, and publicity, and presentation, and even manipulation. Contrast that with Paul in 2 Corinthians 4 or in 1Thessalonians 1:5. The Word needs to come with the power of the Spirit.

We have a Scots phrase, “It’s better felt than telt.” I cannot really describe what happens. But I know when it happens. I know when there is what we used to call ‘the unction’. I know when the room is absolutely still, and you can hear a pin drop, and every word seems to go like an arrow into the hearts of the people. I know what it is to be under the conviction of sin.

The Necessity of the Spirit

Surely our theology tells us, Christ tells us, someone cannot even see the kingdom of God, let alone enter it, unless they are born again (John 3)? Being born again is an indicative, not an imperative. We can no more command people to be born again than we command them to be born. And this is why I find the idea that we can set a target of 5% conversion growth because it’s ‘doable, it’s achievable, measurable etc’, so abhorrent. The point is, it’s not doable. We are preaching to dead stones. No matter how well-organized our outreach is, no matter how well-publicized, no matter how good the music, no matter how clever the speaker with his pre-written, formalistic ‘start with a joke, put in a connect story, refer to the Scriptures, always end up asking people to accept Jesus, get them into an inquiry group’. None of it works unless the Spirit converts. Now, in theory, all evangelicals will accept that. But in practice, we don’t act like we do.

Can These Bones Live?

I used to sit in the old graveyard at St. Peter’s. If I remember rightly, there were around 20 graves, but I was told that there were over 400 people buried there. So many children buried there. So many people buried without identification. I would sit on the bench overlooking that graveyard with the large church wall behind me, complete with its leaking roof and tiny congregation. This in the context of a post-Christian, post-industrial community, where the church was considered at best irrelevant, at worst, an evil perpetrator of injustice and abuse.

I would think of the people that I spoke to and met in the shops and on the streets. How could I reach the Sicilian cafe owner at the bottom of the graveyard? The communist councillor who lived directly opposite the church front door? The drug addict whose door was made of steel and iron in order to prevent the dealers coming in and threatening them. How could I reach the thousands of students who went to the nearby university? Or the 10% of the population that were Muslim in our area?

We had nothing to offer them. The church was old and run down. Our music was not what you would call cutting edge or attractive. The coffee was appalling. Everything about it screamed defeat, and I would cry out literally, “Lord, can these bones live?” And yes, they can.

For a time in our evening service, I preached to single figures. And yet strangely, I remember those as some of the most encouraging times we had. Why? Because despite the discouragement of the numbers, the encouragement of the presence of the Holy Spirit was palpable. And people were converted one by one, slowly. There was occasionally the big bang conversion, but most were gradual, step by step; the defeater beliefs being removed one by one, the eyes slowly opening, the light coming in, until that moment when someone realized, “I believe.” That’s the work of the Holy Spirit.

Our Work and the Spirits Work

There are times when I tried to push that, but that is like a gardener sowing seed, and as the first shoots begin to spring up, pulling on it to make it grow quicker. No, let the earth and the sun and the rain do its work. You tend and you care, you water, you plant, you plough, but it’s God who gives the increase (1 Corinthians 3:6-7). And that’s why, in my view, the 5% figure is almost blasphemous. It is to take on the work of the Holy Spirit. It is to reduce God to a formula.

It is not our responsibility to convert, nor is it our responsibility to convict. The Spirit comes to convict of sin and righteousness, and the judgment to come (John 16:8). I think of the Jehovah’s Witness lady who I’d spent many hours discussing the Trinity and hell, and the scriptures with her. She would come to us in the morning and go to the Jehovah’s Witnesses in the afternoon. One day, I saw her physically transform. I think it’s the only time I’ve ever seen this in 40 years of ministry. But as she was listening to the preaching, her face shone, literally. On the way out the door, she said, “I need to talk to you.” I said, “I think so.” So, I went up during the week, and she told me she’d been converted. I said, “What’s the difference? Why now?” She said, “Oh, David, the Holy Spirit”. Or the Roman Catholic social worker who came because he was working with a family in our congregation where the daughter was a drug addict who so impressed with the parents became not to church, because that would have been a betrayal of his Catholicism, but to the prayer meeting. I remember him praying at one prayer meeting, “Father, I thank you for my new friends, my new family, my new faith.” I stopped the meeting and asked him, “Have you been converted?” And he said, “I think so.” One time he was helping us in our house, redecorating our daughter’s bedroom. And I thanked him profusely because I haven’t a practical bone in my body. And he looked at me and he said, “Oh, Davey, man. No, no, no. I want to thank you. You’re the man who gave me the Holy Spirit.” I laughed and thought, “I must tell that to my Charismatic friends next time.”

Buying the Spirit

Think of Philip and the giving of the Spirit in Acts 8. Simon Magnus thought he could buy the gift of the Spirit but was strongly rebuked. Sometimes evangelistic organisations advertise and fundraise as though they could distribute the gift of the Spirit. On a visit to a Reformed seminary in the US as I was shocked to see EE (Evangelism Explosion) being advertised in this way – “It only takes $1 a soul to bring the gospel in Poland). It was the nearest example of Protestant Indulgences I have come across!

Let me be a little bit careful here. I’m not saying that we don’t do any preparation or use any techniques. That would be absurd. Of course we do. We learn how to speak. But we must be like Elijah in the story of the prophets of Baal (1 Kings 18). We set up the altar, and we may even do something which seems self-defeating – like covering it with water. But let the God who answers by fire, let him be God.

Sometimes I’ve gone into a meeting in my own strength. What I mean by that is I’m confident. I’ve done this before. I know the circumstances. I know the environment. I know the people. It’s almost as if I say to myself, “Hey, David, you’re going to knock this one dead.” I remember one particular meeting where I went in with that attitude. It was a marvellous opportunity with many people who are not Christians. And I blew it. I went home, and I wept. I vowed I would never do that again.

Conclusion

I am reminded of a story about Robert Murray McCheyne. The beadle who was to carry the Bible in front of McCheyne, which is the way it was done in those days (the 19th Century), was waiting for him, and he went to the vestry. The beadle heard McCheyne talking to someone. “I won’t go unless you come with me. I won’t go unless you come with me.” Gingerly, he opened the door, and there was McCheyne on his knees pleading with the Lord to be with him as he proclaimed God’s Word. Surely, brothers and sisters, this is what we need to cry for? This is what we need to pray for. We can do nothing without the Spirit. We can do all things with the Spirit.

Evangelism in the Presbyterian Church – AP

Evangelism and Ecclesiology – AP

https://ap.org.au/2026/11/05/evangelism-and-theology-part-3-of-evangelism/

5 comments

  1. I recall your message to us shortly after we first met.. the above perspective on the Holy Spirit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *