Creation Education Media News reports Politics

Creationism Ban Petition Rejected by Scottish Government.

This is good news – the Scottish Secular Society have failed in their petition to get the Scottish Government to ban creationism – the following report appeared in the Herald.  For the background to the story – see the following links:

The Herald’s report is as follows:

Formal ban on teaching of creationism rejected

The Herald 13 May 2015

CALLS for an official ban on the teaching of young earth creationism in science lessons in Scottish schools have been kicked out by MSPs.

Politicians from across the political spectrum agreed it was unnecessary for the Scottish Government to introduce new guidance on the issue.Instead, MSPs from the Scottish Parliament’s education committee said schools should rely on the professionalism of teachers and the existing inspection regime to ensure such theories were not taught as scientific fact.

Last year, the Scottish Secularist Society (SSS) urged ministers to bar the “presentation” of young earth doctrines as viable alternatives to the established science of evolution in the classroom.The SSS lodged the petition after claiming schools were being subjected to an “attack” on established scientific theories from imported US doctrines known as creation science and intelligent design.

However, Dr Alasdair Allan, Minister for Learning and Science, wrote to MSPs saying it was preferable to leave the curriculum to teachers and “enable them to exercise their professional judgement…. rather than legislate to ban issues like creationism in specific areas”.

Mr Allan also said no concerns had been raised with national inspection body Education Scotland and stressed existing guidance on the science curriculum made no reference to young earth creationism as a “legitimate scientific theory”.

 Closing the SSS petition, SNP MSP Stewart Maxwell, the convener of the education committee, said: “It should therefore not be taught as part of science lessons.”

Rev David Robertson, the next Free Church of Scotland Moderator, welcomed the decision, but went on to accuse the SSS of scaremongering.He said: “The clear position of the Scottish Government and the teaching unions is that we don’t need politicians telling teachers what they should teach and this is a position we completely agree with.

“The secularists failed to produce any concrete evidence that creationism was being taught as science in any classroom in Scotland, so in reality this petition was an extraordinary waste of parliamentary time. I am quite convinced that our politicians have better things to do.”


  1. What possible value or gain would teaching creationism be? I don’t get it. Why do you want some families to keep their children ignorant? Social Darwinism? Do you think, “hey, if we keep them dumb, I might have a chance to find a decent job?”
    It’s the only reason I can think of.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: